An old stone arch bridge spans a river gorge at golden hour, a footpath climbing the hills beyond.
AI-generated image

ResilienceStories and mindset

Pushed Out, Turned Away, Sidelined, Demoted: 4 Doctors Who Overcame Adversity

Virginia Apgar, Helen Taussig, Werner Forssmann and Katalin Karikó were pushed out, turned away and demoted. What each did next, and the rule it teaches you.

Contents
  1. The four stories at a glance
  2. 1. Virginia Apgar: pushed out of surgery, she built a new specialty
  3. 2. Helen Taussig: turned away, she turned her hearing loss into a method
  4. 3. Werner Forssmann: sidelined over an experiment, honored 27 years later
  5. 4. Katalin Karikó: demoted, then a Nobel Prize
  6. What the four stories have in common
  7. Your comeback rules, in one table
  8. Sources

Four people medicine tried to turn away. One was steered out of surgery, one was refused a degree, one was sidelined after an experiment his bosses would not approve, and one was demoted after years of rejected grants. Each went on to change how medicine works: a newborn score used in delivery rooms worldwide, the operation that saved "blue babies," the cardiac catheter and the science behind mRNA vaccines.

If a score, a committee letter or a program director just told you no, these stories are not here to tell you everything happens for a reason. They are here because each one shows a specific move, and each move maps onto a rule you can use this week. Every fact below is linked to its source.

The four stories at a glance

WhoThe setbackWhat came nextYour rule this week
Virginia ApgarSteered out of surgeryBuilt anesthesiology at Columbia; created the Apgar scoreYou can rank more than one specialty in the Match
Helen TaussigRefused a Harvard degree; lost her hearingFounded pediatric cardiology; conceived the blue baby operationUSMLE accommodations take about 60 business days
Werner ForssmannIgnored, then sidelined after a self-experimentShared the 1956 Nobel PrizeAt FERPA-covered schools, you can see your records within 45 days
Katalin KarikóDemoted after years of rejected grantsShared the 2023 Nobel PrizeOne collaborator can restart a stalled path

1. Virginia Apgar: pushed out of surgery, she built a new specialty

Apgar won a surgical internship at Columbia and, by the National Library of Medicine's account, performed brilliantly. Her chair of surgery, Allen Whipple, still told her not to continue: the women he had trained in surgery had not been able to build careers, and he worried about women surgeons' prospects during the Depression (NLM, Changing the Face of Medicine; NLM Profiles in Science). He suggested anesthesiology, a field that was only then becoming a physician specialty rather than a nursing role.

She took it. In 1938 she became director of Presbyterian Hospital's new anesthesia division (Embryo Project Encyclopedia). In 1949 she became the first woman named a full professor at Columbia's College of Physicians and Surgeons, and in 1952 she introduced the Apgar score, the first standardized way to judge a newborn's transition to life outside the womb (NLM).

The move: pivot without quitting medicine. Apgar did not treat "not surgery" as "not medicine." She took the door that was open and made it the most important room in the building.

The rule most applicants learn too late: you can rank programs in more than one specialty on the same rank order list, and the matching algorithm places you in your most preferred program regardless of its specialty (NRMP). The NRMP itself advises applicants to a competitive specialty to also rank their favorite programs in an alternate specialty (NRMP). Budget for it: the registration fee covers 20 unique programs on your primary list, and each additional rank costs $30 (NRMP).

Do this week: write two sentences on why your backup specialty would genuinely suit you. If you cannot write them, that is your signal to shadow or talk to a resident in that field before rank lists are due.

2. Helen Taussig: turned away, she turned her hearing loss into a method

Taussig wanted to study medicine at Harvard. Harvard let women take courses but would not grant them a medical degree, so she finished at Johns Hopkins and earned her MD in 1927 (Johns Hopkins Sheridan Libraries). At graduation she narrowly missed the internal medicine residency she wanted (American Heart Association). She also lived with dyslexia and a hearing loss that worsened over the years.

Because the stethoscope was hard for her to use, she learned to feel the vibrations of children's heartbeats with her hands and diagnose from what she felt (AHA). That close study of babies with heart defects led her to the idea behind the first "blue baby" operation, performed at Hopkins in 1944 (Archives of Maryland), and she is regarded as the founder of pediatric cardiology (Johns Hopkins).

The move: build the workaround, then get the support in writing. Taussig's adaptation became a clinical skill. Yours can too, but on exam day a workaround is not enough. You need the accommodation approved before you sit.

The rule: USMLE accommodation requests go to NBME Disability Services through the MyUSMLE portal. The USMLE says to allow approximately 60 business days for a decision on a new request (about 14 business days to repeat accommodations you already had). For a June to August eligibility period, it suggests submitting by early March (USMLE).

Do this week: 60 business days is about 12 calendar weeks. Count back 12 weeks from the start of your eligibility window, not your test date, and put that date in your calendar. Ask your school's disability office which documentation it can provide for the request.

3. Werner Forssmann: sidelined over an experiment, honored 27 years later

In 1929, as a 25-year-old junior doctor in Eberswalde near Berlin, Forssmann was refused permission to try his idea on patients. So he passed a rubber tube through a vein in his own arm into his heart and documented it with an X-ray (Humboldt University Berlin). His report appeared in the journal Klinische Wochenschrift in November 1929 (Siemens Healthineers MedMuseum). It drew little interest from the medical world, and Ferdinand Sauerbruch, his new chief at Berlin's Charité, thought little of it (Humboldt University). The popular telling says Sauerbruch fired him; a history paper from the German Cardiac Society argues that the "genius versus ignorant boss" version is too simple (DGK historical archive).

Either way, cardiology moved on without him. He retrained in urology and from 1950 practiced as a urologist in Bad Kreuznach (Nobel Prize biography). In 1956 he shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with André Cournand and Dickinson Richards, for discoveries concerning heart catheterization (NobelPrize.org).

The move: keep the record. The X-ray outlived every criticism. A word of caution, though: Forssmann's method was to break the rules, and that is not the lesson. Today an unapproved self-experiment would end a career, not start one. The lesson is the evidence.

The rule: at schools covered by FERPA, you have the right to inspect and review your education records, and the school must respond within a reasonable time and no later than 45 days after your request (U.S. Department of Education, 34 CFR 99.10).

Do this week: if you face a promotions committee, probation or an appeal, ask in writing for your education records, such as grades, evaluations and other records about you that the school keeps, and save the dated email. Then check your appeal deadline in the handbook: it can be shorter than 45 days, so file on time even if the records have not arrived. The 14-day comeback plan after a dismissal walks through the rest.

4. Katalin Karikó: demoted, then a Nobel Prize

Karikó, a biochemist, spent years at the University of Pennsylvania trying to fund research on messenger RNA, with little encouragement from funders or journals. In 1995 Penn demoted her from a faculty position because her bosses judged the work unproductive (Times Higher Education).

She kept working. In the late 1990s she met the immunologist Drew Weissman at a Penn photocopier while they were copying journal articles (Penn Center for Innovation). Together they found in 2005 that modifying RNA's building blocks cut the unwanted inflammatory reaction to lab-made mRNA and increased protein production, the groundwork for the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines (NobelPrize.org). She left Penn in 2013 for BioNTech (THE), and in 2023 she and Weissman shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine (NobelPrize.org).

The move: find the one person who needs what you can do. Karikó could make mRNA; Weissman needed it for vaccine work. The demotion took away her title, not her skill, and the skill found its use through one partner.

Do this week: after a setback, one research or clinical collaborator is worth more than ten generic networking events. Pick five recent papers in the specialty you want. Most journal articles name a corresponding author with an email address. Send each a three-line note: one sentence on what you can do (data entry, chart review, literature searches, statistics), how many hours a week you can give, and one specific task you could start on. If clinical experience is your gap, U.S. clinical observerships are another way in.

What the four stories have in common

None of them waited for permission to stay in medicine. Each lost the specific thing they wanted (a surgical career, a Harvard degree, a cardiology post, a faculty position) and kept the larger thing, which was the work. And the timelines were long: Apgar's score came 14 years after she took charge of Presbyterian's new anesthesia division, Forssmann's Nobel came 27 years after his experiment, and Karikó's 28 years after her demotion. A setback measured in months is short by those standards.

The practical lesson is the same one in our companion piece, Rejected, Doubted, Undeterred: 3 Physicians Who Turned Setbacks Into Breakthroughs: a setback is a data point with a deadline attached. Find the deadline first, then decide the move.

Your comeback rules, in one table

If your setback is…The ruleThe number to knowFirst move
Your first-choice specialty is out of reachRank more than one specialty on one list20 programs included; $30 per extra rankWrite the two-sentence case for your backup
You need exam accommodationsApply through NBME Disability ServicesAbout 60 business days for a new request (about 14 to repeat ones you had)Count back 12 weeks from your eligibility window
You face probation, review or dismissalFERPA right to inspect your recordsResponse within 45 days at mostRequest records in writing today; check the appeal deadline
You lost a lab, mentor or positionOne collaborator can restart the pathFive targeted emailsWrite to five corresponding authors this week

If your setback is a failed exam, start with the 90-minute exam autopsy. If it is the Match, read the SOAP 2027 Match Week guide before you need it.

If you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, U.S.). Your school's counseling service and student affairs office can help too.


Sources

  1. National Library of Medicine, Changing the Face of Medicine: Dr. Virginia Apgar
  2. NLM Profiles in Science: Virginia Apgar, biographical overview
  3. Embryo Project Encyclopedia: Virginia Apgar (1909–1974)
  4. Johns Hopkins Sheridan Libraries: The Blue Baby Operation, Helen Taussig
  5. American Heart Association News: Dr. Helen Taussig's work saved blue babies (2024)
  6. Archives of Maryland: Helen Brooke Taussig biography
  7. Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin: Werner Forssmann
  8. Siemens Healthineers MedMuseum: The history of the first heart catheterization
  9. German Cardiac Society historical archive: Forssmann and the self-experiment
  10. NobelPrize.org: Werner Forssmann, biographical
  11. NobelPrize.org: Werner Forssmann, facts
  12. Times Higher Education: Vaccine pioneers overcame rejection and demotion to win Nobel (2023)
  13. Penn Center for Innovation: Weissman and Karikó named Nobel laureates
  14. NobelPrize.org: Katalin Karikó, facts
  15. NRMP: Can I rank multiple specialties?
  16. NRMP: Recommendations for constructing a rank order list
  17. NRMP: How many programs can I rank?
  18. USMLE: Test accommodations
  19. U.S. Department of Education: FERPA, 34 CFR Part 99

MedRise Resilience shares stories and educational guidance. It is not medical, legal or mental-health advice. Rules, fees and timelines change; check the official source for your exam, Match cycle or school before you act.

Came back from a setback of your own? Your story could help the next person.

Write it up for MedRise Perspectives: 600 to 1,200 words, published under your name, with a decision usually within one day.

Book a free strategy call

Ten minutes to look at your exam date, your scores and what is getting in the way.